Carousel vs Video vs Story Ads: What Converts Better?

Ready to boost your conversions today? Don’t wait—learn which ad format transforms clicks into customers with proven results!

The key phrase “converts better” is essential here and will guide our comparison of Carousel vs Video vs Story Ads throughout this article.

Table of Contents

1. Carousel Ads: Multi‑Product Powerhouses

2. Video Ads: Grab Attention with Motion

3. Story Ads: Full‑Screen, Full Attention

4. Performance Metrics Compared

5. Choosing the Right Format to Convert Better

1. Carousel Ads: Multi‑Product Powerhouses

Carousel ads enable showcasing up to 10 products or features in one ad—a format ideal for e-commerce catalogs, storytelling, or step-by-step guides. Benchmarks show:

• Conversion Rate (CR): 1.39%, compared to 1.26% for image ads, making Carousels more effective

• Return on Ad Spend (ROAS): 209 vs video’s 138

• Cost per Acquisition (CPA): lower at ~$15.47 vs $27.97 for images

Carousel ads balance reach, interaction, and conversion. Use them to tell a visual narrative—each card builds on the story, guiding viewers toward purchase.

2. Video Ads: Grab Attention with Motion

Video ads are powerful engagement drivers:

• Highest Click-Through Rate (CTR): 0.98%, surpassed carousel’s 0.92% and image’s 0.88%

• Especially effective for awareness and storytelling

• Often higher CPA and lower ROAS compared to Carousels, indicating powerful reach but less conversion efficiency

Best practices include:

• Front-loading hooks in the first 3–5 seconds

• Including captions, given silent auto-play

• Using vertical or square formats for mobile feeds

3. Story Ads: Full‑Screen, Full Attention

Story Ads (Instagram Stories or Facebook Stories) fill the entire screen, offering high engagement via immersive visuals:

• Vertical format optimized for mobile

• Expiring after 24 hours—ideal for limited-time offers

• Swipe-up CTAs drive targeted traffic

While specific benchmarks vary, Stories often yield higher view-through rates and attention metrics. They convert best when featuring direct promos or urgent calls to action.

4. Performance Metrics Compared

Estimated from comparative performance; CTR highest but conversion efficiency lower.

Carousel sets the benchmark for conversions and ROI, while Video excels at initial engagement and reach. Story Ads offer quick impact and immersive experiences, making them best suited for fast-moving promotions.

5. Choosing the Right Format to Convert Better

Guidelines for Selection:

• Goal = Conversions (purchase, signup) → Use Carouselads for lowest CPA & highest ROAS

• Goal = Awareness or Engagement → Use Video ads to capture attention with motion

• Goal = Promo or Urgency → Use Story ads for swipe-up immediacy

Practical Tips:

• Use Carousel for product catalogs, process breakdowns, or narrative storytelling

• Use Video for demos, testimonials, brand stories

• Use Stories for flash deals, event signups, or reminders

Hybrid approach:Start with a Video or Story Ad to build interest, then retarget with a Carousel ad displaying relevant products to maximize conversion.

Call to Action

Ready to find out which Facebook ad type converts better for your business? Start by testing one full-funnel strategy: Awareness (Video) → Consideration (Story promo) → Conversion (Carousel). Track CTR, CPA, and ROAS—and optimize using real-time metrics.

By understanding how each ad format performs—and strategically using them—you can develop campaigns that not only engage but also convert better. Let the data guide your strategy, test smartly, and enjoy boosting your ROI across the funnel.

Want the full ROI playbook? Subscribe now for exclusive Facebook ad performance insights and benchmark updates.